Sam Groth’s departure from the Victorian Liberal Party’s frontbench last Friday has cast shadows on the already shaky leadership of John Pesutto, as political tensions rise following recent court rulings. The announcement came less than 24 hours after Federal Court judge David O'Callaghan exposed serious flaws in Pesutto’s conduct during legal proceedings involving former MP Moira Deeming, whom Pesutto was found to have defamed.
Groth, the member for Nepean and previously aligned with the Liberal Party since the lead-up to the 2022 state election, expressed his decision wasn't made lightly. He stated, "It is with regret... I can no longer continue to serve in this role". His resignation as the opposition spokesman for tourism, sport, events, and youth revealed his moral stance following the court’s ruling against Pesutto. Groth clearly articulated his commitment to integrity: "At all times... I have believed in acting with integrity.”
The triggering incident stemmed from events surrounding Deeming’s involvement at the Let Women Speak rally, which was disrupted by neo-Nazi protests. O'Callaghan’s judgment unequivocally criticized Pesutto's handling of the situation, finding him to be "infuriately unresponsive" and lacking credibility on the stand. The judge's conclusions indicated not just the defamation against Deeming, but suggested Pesutto acted with political self-interest rather than genuine concern for party values or public truth.
Despite Groth’s firm stance, the Liberal Party appeared divided following his resignation. Matthew Guy, another prominent party figure and former opposition leader, defended Pesutto, asserting, "John has strong internal support." Even so, some members, such as Bev McArthur, have publicly called for another change at the helm, asking Pesutto to confer with party members to affirm his leadership.
The political chaos bubbled beneath the surface for some time, with whispered concerns about Pesutto’s ability to maintain party unity after the court findings. Some others within the party downplayed Groth's departure as inconsequential, with one senior party member deriding him with, "What a wanker."
Groth’s unanticipated resignation has sparked speculation about the potential for more exits from the opposition ranks, as insiders hint at discontent simmering among colleagues. While many may have been surprised by Groth’s decision and timing—he reportedly notified Pesutto mere minutes before going public—his actions could suggest aspirations for greater influence within the party.
Exploring Groth’s background offers insight. A former professional tennis player with considerable public visibility, he joined politics with aspirations of injecting fresh perspectives. During his brief tenure, he seemed eager to make his mark, showcasing his focus on tourism and youth issues. One can’t help but wonder how the fallout from his resignation will affect his ambitions moving forward.
The weighing conditions for both the party and Groth are compelling. With upcoming elections looming—November 2026 marks the next state election—the ramifications of internal strife could impede their overall approach to campaigning and organization strategies. It becomes imperative for the Victorian Liberals to mend their ranks and unify their leadership front.
Adding concern to the dynamics, Kim Wells, former treasurer within the Liberal Party, has urged Pesutto to reconsider Deeming’s standing. Wells posited, “The issue surrounding Moira Deeming attending... should have been resolved behind closed doors.” Her insights allude to broader fractures and strained loyalties within the party.
Groth’s sudden departure from the frontbench is more than just one man stepping down. It's indicative of the inner turmoil plaguing the Victorian Liberal Party as they navigate the contentious legacy of leadership decisions. While Groth’s loyalty may still be to the people of Nepean and the party's broader vision, the path to rebuilding relationships and trust will require concerted efforts from all involved.
What lies next for Groth and Pesutto remains unclear, yet the waves from this resignation are sure to be felt for some time to come, creating ripples throughout the Victorian political sphere. The challenge remains for Pesutto to consolidate his power and quell calls for change within the party as they look forward to the impending election.
