Percy Jackson Finale Surprises Fans With Post Credit Twist

The curtain has closed on the second season of Percy Jackson and the Olympians, but fans barely had time to catch their breath before a wave of new revelations, speculation, and anticipation swept through the fandom. The Season 2 finale, titled "The Fleece Works Its Magic Too Well," delivered a dramatic showdown at Camp Half-Blood, a bold reimagining of key book moments, and a post-credit scene that has everyone talking about the future of the series—and what might come next on Disney+ and Hulu.

According to Decider, the post-credit scene in the Season 2 finale features Circe, played by Rosemarie Dewitt, presenting statues of Percy (Walker Scobell) and Annabeth (Leah Sava Jeffries) to a crowd, declaring that "there are a limited number of spots in the course, but the results are undeniable." This moment, originally intended for Episode 5, was repositioned to serve as a capstone to Percy’s arc on Circe’s Island. Executive producer Craig Silverstein explained to Entertainment Weekly, “That piece was sort of floating out there as a tag that we hadn’t really done in the show before.” Star Walker Scobell added, “I just think it’s a perfect way to show that the world just goes on. It’s like, this is just a challenge for another person now.”

But what does this cryptic coda mean for the story’s future? The scene also features Hylla (Jasmine Vega), a character who, in Rick Riordan’s Heroes of Olympus books, plays a pivotal role alongside her sister Reyna after escaping Circe’s Island. The non-destruction of Circe’s Island in the show leaves the door open for future adaptations, though Silverstein was quick to clarify that the creative team is “so neck deep in the Olympians saga” that they aren’t currently planning a full-fledged Heroes of Olympus series. “Hylla’s story is really told in Heroes of Olympus… So I guess there’s time to patch that,” he told the outlet.

This finale’s ambitious scope extended far beyond the post-credits. As Reactor reported, the episode kicked off with the heroes returning to Camp Half-Blood, only to find the camp besieged by Kronos’ followers and monsters. Clarisse’s desperate race to deliver the Golden Fleece on foot set the stage for a climactic battle, with Percy rallying the demigods at the Big House for a last stand. The decision to stage such a large-scale confrontation outside Camp Half-Blood, in addition to the previous episode’s showdown on the Princess Andromeda, was a bold departure from the books. Yet, as noted by Minute Media, it largely paid off by heightening the sense of urgency and spectacle.

One of the finale’s most memorable moments came when Timothy Simons’ Tantalus, the camp’s much-maligned administrator, met his end via fireball just as he believed his curse had been lifted. The send-off was both shocking and comical, injecting a bit of levity into the chaos. Meanwhile, the stakes continued to rise as Clarisse encountered betrayal—her supposed allies turned out to be traitors working for Luke, but Annabeth and Grover swooped in to save the day. The ensuing battle was among the show’s most epic sequences to date, with Percy’s leadership finally coming into full focus as he led the defense against the Laistrygonians and rallied his friends to protect Thalia’s tree.

Luke’s plan to revive Thalia with the Golden Fleece, aiming to have her fulfill the Great Prophecy instead of Percy, added a layer of intrigue. The action reached its crescendo as Clarisse, with Annabeth and Grover’s help, delivered the Fleece to Thalia’s tree. The result was explosive—Thalia’s emergence was more violent than expected, unleashing lightning that knocked Percy unconscious and temporarily halting Luke’s assault.

Yet, not all changes from the books were met with universal acclaim. As highlighted by Minute Media, the show diverged significantly in its portrayal of Thalia’s transformation. Instead of being turned into a tree because she was dying, the series reveals that Zeus intervened to save her from the Furies, transforming her because she refused to embrace her role as his daughter. This shift dramatically alters Thalia’s relationship with the gods and potentially sets her up as a mirror to Luke—a demigod with reasons to resent Olympus, but who must choose her own path. “This is the first one I’m side-eyeing, as it doesn’t feel all that necessary and could easily go sideways,” the reviewer admitted, expressing hope that Season 3 will handle the new dynamic thoughtfully.

The emotional stakes of the finale were also a point of contention. While the battle was suspenseful and visually impressive, some critics felt that the episode failed to give enough weight to injuries, casualties, and betrayals. The relationships between characters like Clarisse and her betrayers lacked the emotional depth needed to make their twists truly resonate. Nevertheless, moments like Percy’s speech to the demigods and Clarisse’s character growth were praised for grounding the spectacle in genuine character development.

As the dust settled, the narrative threads set up a tantalizing path for Season 3. The final moments saw Poseidon visiting Percy in a dream, warning him of the coming war and tasking Tyson with forging new weapons. The sense of looming conflict was palpable, and fans didn’t have to wait long for more news: a teaser for the third season appeared in the end credits, showing Annabeth leading Percy onto a school dance floor—a hint at fresh adventures and challenges ahead.

Reactor confirmed that Disney+ had renewed Percy Jackson and the Olympians for a third season even before the second season aired, a testament to the platform’s confidence in the series. The upcoming season will adapt The Titan’s Curse, the third book in Riordan’s saga, which has never been brought to the screen before. New cast members will join the ensemble, including Kate McKinnon as Aphrodite, Dafne Keen as Artemis, Saara Chaudry as Zoë Nightshade, Holt McCallany as Atlas, David Costabile as Dr. Thorn, Levi Chrisopulos and Olive Abercrombie as Nico and Bianca di Angelo, and Jesse L. Martin as Frederick Chase.

Star Walker Scobell, reflecting on the shift to uncharted territory, told Variety, “I almost feel like there’s less pressure, because I don’t think there’s anything to really compare it to. I thought Logan Lerman had a wonderful performance as Percy Jackson, but now I’m on my own.” The plot will center on the disappearance of Artemis, a mysterious monster, and a race against time before the winter solstice—high stakes that promise to keep viewers on the edge of their seats.

For those eager to catch up or rewatch, the first two seasons are streaming on Disney+ and Hulu, with subscription options starting at $10.99 per month with ads and $18.99 per month ad-free. Disney+ bundles with Hulu, Max, and ESPN+ are also available, offering savings for those looking to expand their streaming lineup.

As Percy Jackson and the Olympians readies its next chapter, the blend of bold storytelling choices, fresh interpretations, and a growing cast ensures that the saga remains as unpredictable—and compelling—as ever.