Matthew Morrison, best known for his role as Will Schuester on the hit TV series Glee, is once again lighting up the Broadway stage after more than a decade away. This time, he’s stepping into the spotlight as the lead in the jukebox musical Just in Time at the Circle in the Square Theatre, a role he took over from fellow Glee alum Jonathan Groff. Morrison’s return, running from April 1 to April 19, 2026, marks a homecoming for the 47-year-old performer whose career began on Broadway long before his television fame.
Morrison’s reappearance on Broadway was punctuated by a red-carpet appearance at the opening night of Dog Day Afternoon in New York City on March 30. There, he spoke candidly about his journey back to the stage and the friendships that have shaped his career. In an exclusive conversation with PEOPLE magazine, Morrison revealed a wish that’s sure to delight fans of both theater and television: he’d love to share the stage with his former Glee co-star Jane Lynch.
“She’s one of my favorite people, and we just have a great friendship,” Morrison told PEOPLE on the red carpet. “She’s done Broadway as well, so she’s not a stranger to it, so it’d be so much fun to do it together.” He didn’t hesitate to add, “I would love to make that happen.”
For viewers who remember the on-screen rivalry between Morrison’s Will Schuester and Lynch’s Sue Sylvester, the prospect of the two teaming up in a Broadway production is especially tantalizing. Off-screen, though, the pair’s relationship is anything but adversarial. Morrison spoke warmly of Lynch, reflecting on the bond they developed during their years on Glee. “She was a godsend,” he said during a recent episode of the That’s What You Really Missed podcast hosted by Glee castmates Jenna Ushkowitz and Kevin McHale. “We became really, really close on that show. We don’t talk as much, but we still communicate every now and then, and I just love that woman. For me, as you guys looked at me as the adult and that figure, she was that for me. She was that person I was like, ‘Oh, I need to look up to her, and see what she’s doing.’ I loved working with her.”
Jane Lynch, now 65, has built her own impressive stage résumé since her days as the acerbic cheer coach on Glee. She made her Broadway debut in 2012 as Miss Hannigan in Annie, a role that showcased her comedic timing and stage presence. In 2022, she returned to Broadway in the revival of Funny Girl, playing Mrs. Rosie Brice, mother to Lea Michele’s Fanny Brice—another Glee connection. Reflecting on her love for live theater, Lynch told Playbill, “My favorite thing about live performing is that you’re a part of a group and you kind of forget your own individual identity and work for this group on putting on the show.” She added, “I would love to. It’s the actor’s life for me, man. I love being onstage.”
The admiration is clearly mutual. Morrison recalled how Lynch’s humor would often break his composure on set. “I did laugh all the time,” he admitted. “I ruined so many takes because I could not hold it together.” Their camaraderie extended beyond the small screen, with Lynch supporting Morrison’s Broadway run as J.M. Barrie in Finding Neverland in 2015, the same year Glee ended. Their enduring friendship, even if less frequent in communication these days, is a testament to the deep bonds forged in the world of entertainment.
Morrison’s own Broadway journey began back in 1998 with a role in Footloose. He went on to appear in Hairspray and South Pacific, and earned a Tony nomination for his performance in the 2005 production of The Light in the Piazza. Now, in Just in Time, he’s stepping into the shoes of Bobby Darin, a role previously inhabited by Jonathan Groff, another Glee veteran. The show itself is tailored to highlight the unique talents of its lead, and Morrison’s arrival has been met with enthusiasm from the production team.
Isaac Oliver, the show’s co-book writer, expressed his excitement in a statement to The Hollywood Reporter: “Our show is made to fit like a glove around all kinds of virtuoso performers. I’m thrilled to get back in there and tailor the material so it’s personal to Matthew Morrison, his journey, his many talents, and to welcome him back home to Broadway where he belongs.”
For Morrison, the return isn’t just about revisiting old haunts—it’s about embracing new challenges and reconnecting with the roots of his craft. The Circle in the Square Theatre, with its intimate setting, offers a different kind of energy from the large ensemble work of Glee. Yet, the spirit of collaboration and community remains strong, something Morrison clearly values. “Our show is made to fit like a glove around all kinds of virtuoso performers,” Oliver said. “I’m thrilled to get back in there and tailor the material so it’s personal to Matthew Morrison, his journey, his many talents, and to welcome him back home to Broadway where he belongs.”
Fans of Glee and Broadway alike have reason to celebrate Morrison’s return—and perhaps to hope for that onstage reunion with Jane Lynch. Both performers have demonstrated a deep love for theater and a willingness to take on new challenges, whether it’s Lynch’s comedic villainy or Morrison’s heartfelt portrayals. Their mutual respect and affection could one day translate into a must-see theatrical event.
Until then, Morrison is focused on making the most of his current run in Just in Time. The show, which runs until April 19, 2026, promises to showcase the many facets of his talent, from singing and dancing to the kind of heartfelt storytelling that made him a beloved figure on Glee. As Broadway continues to evolve and welcome back familiar faces, Morrison’s journey serves as a reminder of the enduring power of live performance and the bonds it creates—onstage and off.
With Morrison’s passion for the stage reignited and his sights set on future collaborations, Broadway audiences can expect more surprises, more reunions, and, if he has his way, perhaps a little more of that Glee magic in the years to come.